Few people have watched American elections more closely, or for longer, than Larry Sabato. From his perch at the University of Virginia, where he founded and still runs the Center for Politics and publishes the forecasting newsletter that made his name, he has spent decades tracking the country's political weather. So when a man of his temperament, more given to careful prediction than to alarm, says the United States is living through its most partisan era in over a century, it is worth pausing over the claim.
That is precisely what he now argues. The polarisation of American life, in his reading, has passed beyond the ordinary back and forth of a two party system and hardened into something closer to tribal enmity. The two sides no longer merely disagree about policy. They increasingly regard one another not as rivals to be beaten at the next election but as enemies to be defeated, and that shift, he warns, changes the nature of the democratic contest itself.
A number that should unsettle everyone
Sabato reaches for a striking figure to make the point. In one survey of a thousand supporters of Donald Trump, a clear majority, some 51 percent, agreed that the states that vote Democratic should be allowed to break away from the Union altogether. That so many citizens of a single country could contemplate its dissolution with equanimity is, for Sabato, a measure of how far the sense of shared national belonging has frayed.
What troubles him as much as the number is what lies behind it, which he describes as the loss of a certain sportsmanlike spirit that once held the system together. For most of the modern era, he argues, Americans could lose an election and still accept the winner as legitimate, could oppose a president fiercely and still regard the office as belonging to the whole country. That reflex, the willingness to grant the other side its victories, is the quiet machinery on which democracy runs, and it is wearing out.
How it hardened
The change did not happen overnight, and the data trace its arc. Where once partisans mostly saw their opponents as wrong, now they see them as bad. Surveys have found the share of Republicans and Democrats who regard the other party as more immoral than ordinary Americans climbing sharply over the past decade, until large majorities on both sides hold that view. Once a rival becomes a moral inferior rather than a fellow citizen with different ideas, compromise starts to look less like statesmanship and more like surrender.






